Introduction
Choosing the right dog treats can feel overwhelming with so many options on the market. Whether you're looking for dental health benefits, natural ingredients, or simply something your furry friend will love, the decision often comes down to finding the perfect balance of quality, value, and your dog's specific needs.
Today we're comparing three highly-rated dog treats that have earned thousands of positive reviews from pet parents: Greenies Original Teenie Dental Treats, Buddy Biscuits Peanut Butter Treats, and Milk-Bone Brushing Chews Large. Each serves a different purpose and targets different dog sizes, making this comparison particularly valuable for understanding which treat is right for your specific situation.
We'll dive deep into the features, benefits, and drawbacks of each option to help you make an informed decision that both you and your dog will be happy with.
Our Top Pick
Greenies
Greenies Original Teenie Dental Dog Treats, 43 Count
Best Overall (Size-Dependent Winner):
After thorough analysis, we can't declare a single winner because each treat excels in its intended category. The decision comes down to your dog's size first, then your priorities regarding dental health versus value.
| Feature | Greenies Original Teenie | Buddy Biscuits Peanut Butter | Milk-Bone Brushing Chews |
|---|---|---|---|
| Our Score | 9.8/10 | 9.8/10 | 9.8/10 |
| Price | $17.98 | $13.49 | $14.98 |
| Amazon Rating | 4.8/5 (68,234 reviews) | 4.7/5 (5,306 reviews) | 4.7/5 (15,335 reviews) |
| Count/Weight | 43 treats (12 oz) | 3.5 lbs bulk | 25 treats (2.1 lbs) |
| Dog Size | 5-15 lbs | All sizes | 50+ lbs |
| Primary Benefit | Dental health | Natural nutrition | Dental health |
| Flavor | Original | Peanut butter | Chicken |
| Special Features | Reduces tartar 47% | No corn/soy | VOHC certified |
Detailed Comparison: Dental Health Benefits
Greenies Original Teenie
Greenies takes the crown for dental health claims with impressive credentials. These treats are veterinarian-recommended and clinically proven to reduce tartar by 47%. The unique texture and shape are specifically designed to clean teeth down to the gumline while supporting oral microbiome health. The treats work mechanically as dogs chew, scraping away plaque and tartar buildup.
Milk-Bone Brushing Chews
Milk-Bone's offering is the only one in our comparison that's certified by the Veterinary Oral Health Council (VOHC), which is the gold standard for dental health claims. The scrubbing action and calcium fortification work together to clean teeth and support healthy gums. However, these benefits are specifically designed for large dogs over 50 pounds.
Buddy Biscuits
While Buddy Biscuits provide some natural cleaning action through their crunchy texture, they're not specifically formulated for dental health. They're more focused on providing wholesome nutrition and great taste rather than therapeutic dental benefits.
Winner: Greenies for small dogs, Milk-Bone for large dogs
Detailed Comparison: Ingredients and Natural Quality
Buddy Biscuits Peanut Butter
Buddy Biscuits shines in the natural ingredients category. Made with whole wheat flour, real peanut butter, and canola oil, these treats contain no corn, soy, or artificial additives. The minimally processed recipe and oven-baked preparation method appeal to health-conscious pet parents. Being made in the USA adds another layer of quality assurance.Greenies Original Teenie
Greenies uses natural ingredients but focuses more on the functional aspects of dental health. While they don't contain artificial preservatives, the formula is more complex to achieve the specific dental benefits. The treats are designed to be easily digestible while maintaining their cleaning effectiveness.Milk-Bone Brushing Chews
Milk-Bone takes a middle ground approach with no artificial flavors while maintaining their focus on dental functionality. The chicken flavoring is natural, and the treats are formulated to be easily digestible for large dogs.Winner: Buddy Biscuits for the most natural, simple ingredient list
Detailed Comparison: Value and Quantity
Buddy Biscuits Peanut Butter
At $13.49 for 3.5 pounds, Buddy Biscuits offers exceptional value. This bulk quantity means you're getting significantly more treats per dollar compared to the other options. For families with multiple dogs or those who use treats frequently for training, this represents outstanding value.Milk-Bone Brushing Chews
At $14.98 for 25 large treats (2.1 pounds), Milk-Bone offers good value for large dog owners. While the per-treat cost is higher than Buddy Biscuits, you're paying for specialized dental benefits and the larger size appropriate for big dogs.Greenies Original Teenie
At $17.98 for 43 small treats (12 oz), Greenies is the most expensive option per ounce. However, you're paying for veterinary-backed dental benefits and the specialized small dog formulation. The premium price reflects the therapeutic value.Winner: Buddy Biscuits for overall value, though each serves different needs
Detailed Comparison: Dog Size Suitability
Small Dogs (5-15 lbs)
Greenies Original Teenie is specifically formulated for small dogs, making it the clear choice for this category. The size and texture are perfect for smaller mouths, and the dental benefits are particularly valuable for small breeds prone to dental issues.Medium Dogs (15-50 lbs)
Buddy Biscuits works well for medium dogs, though the large biscuit size might require breaking into smaller pieces for some dogs. Neither Greenies Teenie nor Milk-Bone Large are ideal for this size range.Large Dogs (50+ lbs)
Milk-Bone Brushing Chews are designed specifically for large dogs and provide the appropriate size and dental benefits. Buddy Biscuits could work but might not provide the same level of dental benefit.Winner: Each product wins in its intended size category
Pros and Cons Summary
Greenies Original Teenie Dental Dog Treats, 43 Count - Pros & Cons
thumb_up Pros
- check_circle Veterinarian-recommended with proven results
- check_circle Reduces tartar by 47%
- check_circle Made with natural ingredients
- check_circle Perfect size for small dogs
- check_circle Freshens breath effectively
thumb_down Cons
- cancel Limited to dogs 5-15 lbs only
- cancel Most expensive per ounce
- cancel Requires supervision during chewing
- cancel Potential choking hazard if not properly sized
Buddy Biscuits 3.5 lbs Peanut Butter Dog Treats - Pros & Cons
thumb_up Pros
- check_circle Excellent value with 3.5 lb bulk size
- check_circle Natural, wholesome ingredients
- check_circle No corn, soy, or artificial additives
- check_circle Made in USA
- check_circle Suitable for all dog sizes with supervision
thumb_down Cons
- cancel Large biscuit size may need breaking
- cancel Limited to one flavor option
- cancel Some treats may arrive broken in shipping
- cancel No specific dental health benefits
Milk-Bone Brushing Chews Large 25 Count - Pros & Cons
thumb_up Pros
- check_circle VOHC certified for dental health
- check_circle Perfect size for large dogs
- check_circle Natural chicken flavor
- check_circle Calcium-fortified formula
- check_circle No artificial flavors
thumb_down Cons
- cancel Only suitable for dogs over 50 lbs
- cancel Limited flavor variety
- cancel Requires daily use for best results
- cancel More expensive than basic treats
Final Verdict
After thorough analysis, we can't declare a single winner because each treat excels in its intended category. Here's our recommendation framework:
For most pet parents, the decision comes down to your dog's size first, then your priorities regarding dental health versus value. All three products have earned their high ratings through quality and effectiveness in their respective categories.
Can I give these treats to puppies? expand_more
How often should I give my dog these treats? expand_more
For dental treats like
